banner
[
Bottom of Page]

The following hyper-links are self extracting pkzip files. Each contains four data files for each alternative that will be described in the text below. The data files contain output for the period of study, 1898 through 1997. Each file is approximately 1.7 megabytes in size zipped and 7 megabytes unzipped. Use your browser's "save file" function to save to a directory and then later execute the filename to unzip the files (i.e., run filename.exe). Each zipped file creates four files named filename.elm, filename.q1d, filename.q2d and filename.sgm. Filename.elm contains end-of-month elevation data for the reservoirs, filename.q1d and filename.q2d contain daily flow data for the dams and gage stations, and filename.sgm contains monthly storage data for the reservoir system. For example cwcp.exe creates cwcp.elm, cwcp.q1d, cwcp.q2d and cwcp.sgm.

bar

Preliminary Draft EIS Alternatives

bar

Eight alternatives will be presented in the preliminary Revised Draft EIS (PRDEIS). These alternatives were selected to provide the public the opportunity to understand the effects of each change in operating criteria being considered for potential inclusion in the preferred alternative to be identified in the Revised Draft EIS (RDEIS), which will be prepared following feedback from the public on the PRDEIS. In addition to the Current Water Control Plan (CWCP), the PRDEIS will present effects of three alternatives with varying levels of conservation in droughts (C18, C31, and C44), three alternatives that provide additional fish and wildlife benefits (FW10, FW15, and FW20), and one alternative that has a Mississippi River target at St. Louis (M66). The table below summarizes the eight alternatives to be presented in detail in the PRDEIS scheduled to be released in August 1998.

Description of Preliminary Draft EIS Alternatives

 

Alternative

 

 

PRDEIS ID

 

 

 

Permanent Pool Level

(MAF)

 

Nonnavigation Service Level

 

 

 

 

Navigation Service Level and Season Length Guide Curves

 

 

 

Intrasystem Regulation Criteria

 

Winter

(kcfs)

 

Spring / Fall

(kcfs)

 

Summer

(kcfs)

CWCP

18

12

9

9

Current

Balanced

C18

18

12

9

18

Current

Modified

C31

31

12

9

18

Higher (more conservation)

Modified

C44

44

12

9

18

Highest (most conservation)

Modified

FW10

31

12

9

18

Higher w/ variable service

Modified

FW15

31

12

9

18

Higher w/ variable service

Modified

FW20

18

12

9

9

Highest w/ variable service

Modified

M66

18

12

9

18

Current

Modified

 

To provide additional fish and wildlife benefits, alternatives FW10, FW15, and FW20 have varying service levels through the navigation season. These benefits are provided by releasing additional water (increasing service levels) in either May through mid-June (FW10 and FW15) or April through mid-June (FW20). The value of the number in the ID is the amount of the increased release in thousands of cubic feet per second (kcfs) from Gavins Point Dam in normal years and with no downstream flood control constraints. Reduced service levels are provided during varying portions of the remainder of the navigation season. FW10 and FW15 have minimum navigation service provided in mid-July through mid-August with no flood storage evacuation allowed during this period, and they are spin-offs from alternative C31. Alternative FW20 is the past preferred alternative of the Draft EIS (DEIS). This alternative has a 20 kcfs increase in service level in May through mid-June followed by minimum service to navigation through October. It also has only a 7-month or shorter season in many years. It is a spin-off from an alternative that would have a computer ID of ABAA21, which is not one of the conservation alternatives selected for detailed presentation in the preliminary draft EIS. Extensions to the navigation season occur under this alternative only when there is above normal runoff to evacuate from the mainstem system.

  The eighth alternative includes an additional target release value, a 66,000-cfs target at St. Louis, Missouri, in addition to the normal navigation, water supply, and other release targets for Missouri River authorized purposes. This alternative is a spin-off from the C18 alternative. The St. Louis target is not always met under this alternative due to several constraints. First, tern and plover constraints in the May 10 to August 20 time frame cannot be exceeded. Second, ice conditions are assumed to limit releases to 24 kcfs after December 10.

  The following descriptions provide a link between the more detailed numbering system used for the DEIS and the abbreviated numbering system used for the eight PRDEIS alternatives:

CWCP or
ABAA10
The Current Water Control Plan (CWCP)
'A'     permanent pool level = 18 MAF
BAA water supply: winter = 12, spring/fall = 9, summer = 9 kcfs
'1' guide curves: Master Manual curves w/ 5.5 month minimum season length
'0' intrasystem routine: balances the upper 3 reservoirs
C18 or
ABAD11
'A'     permanent pool level = 18 MAF
BAD water supply: winter = 12, spring/fall = 9, summer = 18 kcfs
'1' guide curves: MM curves w/ 5.5 month minimum season length
'1' intrasystem routine: unbalances the upper 3 reservoirs on a 3-yr cycle
C31 or
CBADC1
'C'     permanent pool level = 31 MAF
BAD water supply: winter = 12, spring/fall = 9, summer = 18 kcfs
'C' guide curves: post DEIS curves w/ 6 month minimum season length
'1' intrasystem routine: unbalances the upper 3 reservoirs on a 3-yr cycle
C44 or
EBAD21
'E'     permanent pool level = 44 MAF
BAD water supply: winter = 12, spring/fall = 9, summer = 18 kcfs
'2' guide curves: the DEIS curves w/ 6 month minimum season length
'1' intrasystem routine: unbalances the upper 3 reservoirs on a 3-yr cycle
FW10 or
CBADMC
and
FW15 or
CBADNC
These alternatives utilize ‘C’ permanent pool level as indicated
and the ‘C’ guide curves (indicated by the last C) with ‘1’ intrasystem routine.
All use the BAD water supply flow series of 12-9-18 kcfs.
The‘M’ and ‘N’ refer to +10, and +15 kcfs, respectively, service level increase.
These alternatives are a shorter period of high flows in the spring and then.
return to full service levels in the fall (after the tern and plover season).
The ‘C’ series has evac toggle = off for a month from July 15 to August 15.
Follows these service levels and ‘C’ navigation guide curves:
  Service Levels ‘C’ Navigation Guide Curves  
Start
M/D
  End
M/D
  Full Service
Flow (kcfs)
  Min Service
Flow (kcfs)
  Full Service
Storage(MAF)
  Min Service
Storage(MAF)
  Evacuation
Toggle2
4/1   5/1   35.0   29.0   56.3   50.2   On
5/1   6/15   45.01   29.0   56.8   50.7   On
6/15   7/15   35.0   29.0   59.2   54.0   On
7/15   8/15   29.0   29.0   ----   ----   Off
8/15   12/1   35.0   29.0   60.0   58.0   On
1 This value is 45.0 kcfs for the +10 series and 50.0 kcfs for the +15 series.
2 If set=on the evacuation toggle overrides the full service flow as needed for evacuation.
The full service flow is used if the storage is at or above full service storage.
The minimum service flow is used if the storage is at or below minimum service storage.
FW20 or
ABAAZ2
The past preferred alternative of the DEIS
‘A’ permanent pool level = 18 MAF
BAA water supply: winter = 12, spring/fall = 9, summer = 9 kcfs
‘Z’ combination for fish and wildlife enhancement (from the DEIS)
‘2’ is a 20-kcfs increase in spring and early summer flows
Uses the ‘2' guide curve w/ 7-month minimum season length
Uses the unbalanced, 3-year cycle routine

Follows these service levels and ‘2’ navigation guide curves:
  Service Levels ‘2’ Navigation Guide Curves  
Start
M/D
  End
M/D
  Full Service
Flow (kcfs)
  Min Service
Flow (kcfs)
  Full Service
Storage(MAF)
  Min Service
Storage(MAF)
  Evacuation
Toggle3
4/1   7/1   55.0   29.0   57.5   54.5   On
7/1   8/1   35.0   29.0   62.5   60.5   On
8/1   11/1   29.0   29.0   ----   ----   On
3 If set = on the evacuation toggle overrides the service flow as needed for evacuation. The full service flow is used if the storage is at or above full service storage. The minimum service flow is used if the storage is at or below minimum service storage.
M66 This alternative, which is a spin-off of C18 (ABAD11), did not have a corresponding number in Volume 1 of the Supporting Technical Reports for the DEIS (see chapter 14); however, it is very similar to CO-121, which had the ‘2’ navigation guide curve instead of the CWCP, or ‘1’ (or current) navigation guide curve and had a summer nonnavigation service level of 25 kcfs, instead of the 18 kcfs used in M66. The ‘-1’ in the DEIS number referred to a St. Louis stage of -1, which corresponds to a discharge of 66 kcfs.


[
Top of Page]   [Master Manual Technical Reports Page]